BJT Voltage Divider Bias Circuit problem

Consider the equation that uses the reverse saturation current

$$I_C=I_S\cdot e^\frac{V_{BE}}{V_T}$$

And then consider what happens for a slight difference in Vbe: -

• If Vbe = 0.70 volts then Ic = 0.394 mA
• If Vbe = 0.68 volts then Ic = 0.183 mA
• If Vbe = 0.72 volts then Ic = 0.851 mA

So choose Vbe carefully or you'll be a mile out.

If you chose Vbe to be 0.72597 volts, Ic would equal 1.07 mA and match your 2nd derivation. It's easy to get fixated on what you believe are correct numbers.

As for the 2nd derivation using Kirchoffs, there is an omission that is relevant and will slightly lower the collector current. The omission I refer to is called \$r_E\$ and is the internal emitter resistance.

In simple terms it equals \$\dfrac{V_T}{I_C}\$

Or about 26 ohms for an \$I_C\$ of about 1 mA and is fairly significant when you consider that \$R_E\$ is only 400 ohms. So, it's best not to get too fixated on some formulae. I'd be interested to know what a sim produces.

You have a bunch of undefined terms in your equations, especially the first set. So we can't tell exactly what you are doing.

It seems you are using two different models for what the transistor will do, and not surprisingly, they have the transistor doing different things. The second model seems to be assuming a fixed gain of 100, which matches your initial verbal description. However, the first model isn't following that. The undefined terms make it unclear, but you have the collector current as a function of the B-E voltage, which is clearly not using a fixed gain approximation.