c++ Threads inside for loop print wrong values
The [&]
syntax is causing i
to be captured by reference. So quite often therefore i
will be further advanced when the thread runs than you might expect. More seriously, the behaviour of your code is undefined if i
goes out of scope before a thread runs.
Capturing i
by value - i.e. std::thread([i](){ print_id(i); })
is the fix.
Two problems:
You have no control over when the thread runs, which means the value of the variable
i
in the lambda might not be what you expect.The variable
i
is local for the loop and the loop only. If the loop finishes before one or more thread runs, those threads will have an invalid reference to a variable whose lifetime have ended.
You can solve both these problems very simply by capturing the variable i
by value instead of by reference. That means each thread will have a copy of the value, and that copy will be made uniquely for each thread.
Another thing :
Do not wait until to have always an ordered sequence: 0, 1, 2, 3, ... because the multithreading execution mode has a specificity: indeterminism.
Indeterminism means that the execution of the same program, under the same conditions, gives a different result.
This is due to the fact that the OS schedules threads differently from one execution to another depending on several parameters: CPU load, priority of other processes, possible system interruptions, ...
Your example contains only 5 threads, so it's simple, try to increase the number of threads, and for example put a sleep in the processing function, you will see that the result can be different from one execution to another .