Can I use return value of INSERT...RETURNING in another INSERT?

The best practice for this situation. Use RETURNING … INTO.

INSERT INTO teams VALUES (...) RETURNING id INTO last_id;

Note this is for PLPGSQL


You can do so starting with Postgres 9.1:

with rows as (
INSERT INTO Table1 (name) VALUES ('a_title') RETURNING id
)
INSERT INTO Table2 (val)
SELECT id
FROM rows

In the meanwhile, if you're only interested in the id, you can do so with a trigger:

create function t1_ins_into_t2()
  returns trigger
as $$
begin
  insert into table2 (val) values (new.id);
  return new;
end;
$$ language plpgsql;

create trigger t1_ins_into_t2
  after insert on table1
for each row
execute procedure t1_ins_into_t2();