Convert Variable Name to String?
TL;DR: Not possible. See 'conclusion' at the end.
There is an usage scenario where you might need this. I'm not implying there are not better ways or achieving the same functionality.
This would be useful in order to 'dump' an arbitrary list of dictionaries in case of error, in debug modes and other similar situations.
What would be needed, is the reverse of the eval() function:
get_indentifier_name_missing_function()
which would take an identifier name ('variable','dictionary',etc) as an argument, and return a string containing the identifier’s name.
Consider the following current state of affairs:
random_function(argument_data)
If one is passing an identifier name ('function','variable','dictionary',etc) argument_data to a random_function() (another identifier name), one actually passes an identifier (e.g.: <argument_data object at 0xb1ce10>) to another identifier (e.g.: <function random_function at 0xafff78>):
<function random_function at 0xafff78>(<argument_data object at 0xb1ce10>)
From my understanding, only the memory address is passed to the function:
<function at 0xafff78>(<object at 0xb1ce10>)
Therefore, one would need to pass a string as an argument to random_function() in order for that function to have the argument's identifier name:
random_function('argument_data')
Inside the random_function()
def random_function(first_argument):
, one would use the already supplied string 'argument_data' to:
serve as an 'identifier name' (to display, log, string split/concat, whatever)
feed the
eval()function in order to get a reference to the actual identifier, and therefore, a reference to the real data:print("Currently working on", first_argument) some_internal_var = eval(first_argument) print("here comes the data: " + str(some_internal_var))
Unfortunately, this doesn't work in all cases. It only works if the random_function() can resolve the 'argument_data' string to an actual identifier. I.e. If argument_data identifier name is available in the random_function()'s namespace.
This isn't always the case:
# main1.py
import some_module1
argument_data = 'my data'
some_module1.random_function('argument_data')
# some_module1.py
def random_function(first_argument):
print("Currently working on", first_argument)
some_internal_var = eval(first_argument)
print("here comes the data: " + str(some_internal_var))
######
Expected results would be:
Currently working on: argument_data
here comes the data: my data
Because argument_data identifier name is not available in the random_function()'s namespace, this would yield instead:
Currently working on argument_data
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "~/main1.py", line 6, in <module>
some_module1.random_function('argument_data')
File "~/some_module1.py", line 4, in random_function
some_internal_var = eval(first_argument)
File "<string>", line 1, in <module>
NameError: name 'argument_data' is not defined
Now, consider the hypotetical usage of a get_indentifier_name_missing_function() which would behave as described above.
Here's a dummy Python 3.0 code: .
# main2.py
import some_module2
some_dictionary_1 = { 'definition_1':'text_1',
'definition_2':'text_2',
'etc':'etc.' }
some_other_dictionary_2 = { 'key_3':'value_3',
'key_4':'value_4',
'etc':'etc.' }
#
# more such stuff
#
some_other_dictionary_n = { 'random_n':'random_n',
'etc':'etc.' }
for each_one_of_my_dictionaries in ( some_dictionary_1,
some_other_dictionary_2,
...,
some_other_dictionary_n ):
some_module2.some_function(each_one_of_my_dictionaries)
# some_module2.py
def some_function(a_dictionary_object):
for _key, _value in a_dictionary_object.items():
print( get_indentifier_name_missing_function(a_dictionary_object) +
" " +
str(_key) +
" = " +
str(_value) )
######
Expected results would be:
some_dictionary_1 definition_1 = text_1
some_dictionary_1 definition_2 = text_2
some_dictionary_1 etc = etc.
some_other_dictionary_2 key_3 = value_3
some_other_dictionary_2 key_4 = value_4
some_other_dictionary_2 etc = etc.
......
......
......
some_other_dictionary_n random_n = random_n
some_other_dictionary_n etc = etc.
Unfortunately, get_indentifier_name_missing_function() would not see the 'original' identifier names (some_dictionary_,some_other_dictionary_2,some_other_dictionary_n). It would only see the a_dictionary_object identifier name.
Therefore the real result would rather be:
a_dictionary_object definition_1 = text_1
a_dictionary_object definition_2 = text_2
a_dictionary_object etc = etc.
a_dictionary_object key_3 = value_3
a_dictionary_object key_4 = value_4
a_dictionary_object etc = etc.
......
......
......
a_dictionary_object random_n = random_n
a_dictionary_object etc = etc.
So, the reverse of the eval() function won't be that useful in this case.
Currently, one would need to do this:
# main2.py same as above, except:
for each_one_of_my_dictionaries_names in ( 'some_dictionary_1',
'some_other_dictionary_2',
'...',
'some_other_dictionary_n' ):
some_module2.some_function( { each_one_of_my_dictionaries_names :
eval(each_one_of_my_dictionaries_names) } )
# some_module2.py
def some_function(a_dictionary_name_object_container):
for _dictionary_name, _dictionary_object in a_dictionary_name_object_container.items():
for _key, _value in _dictionary_object.items():
print( str(_dictionary_name) +
" " +
str(_key) +
" = " +
str(_value) )
######
In conclusion:
- Python passes only memory addresses as arguments to functions.
- Strings representing the name of an identifier, can only be referenced back to the actual identifier by the
eval()function if the name identifier is available in the current namespace. - A hypothetical reverse of the
eval()function, would not be useful in cases where the identifier name is not 'seen' directly by the calling code. E.g. inside any called function. - Currently one needs to pass to a function:
- the string representing the identifier name
- the actual identifier (memory address)
This can be achieved by passing both the 'string' and eval('string') to the called function at the same time. I think this is the most 'general' way of solving this egg-chicken problem across arbitrary functions, modules, namespaces, without using corner-case solutions. The only downside is the use of the eval() function which may easily lead to unsecured code. Care must be taken to not feed the eval() function with just about anything, especially unfiltered external-input data.
Totally possible with the python-varname package (python3):
from varname import nameof
s = 'Hey!'
print (nameof(s))
Output:
s
Install:
pip3 install varname
Or get the package here:
https://github.com/pwwang/python-varname
as long as it's a variable and not a second class, this here works for me:
def print_var_name(variable):
for name in globals():
if eval(name) == variable:
print name
foo = 123
print_var_name(foo)
>>>foo
this happens for class members:
class xyz:
def __init__(self):
pass
member = xyz()
print_var_name(member)
>>>member
ans this for classes (as example):
abc = xyz
print_var_name(abc)
>>>abc
>>>xyz
So for classes it gives you the name AND the properteries
I searched for this question because I wanted a Python program to print assignment statements for some of the variables in the program. For example, it might print "foo = 3, bar = 21, baz = 432". The print function would need the variable names in string form. I could have provided my code with the strings "foo","bar", and "baz", but that felt like repeating myself. After reading the previous answers, I developed the solution below.
The globals() function behaves like a dict with variable names (in the form of strings) as keys. I wanted to retrieve from globals() the key corresponding to the value of each variable. The method globals().items() returns a list of tuples; in each tuple the first item is the variable name (as a string) and the second is the variable value. My variablename() function searches through that list to find the variable name(s) that corresponds to the value of the variable whose name I need in string form.
The function itertools.ifilter() does the search by testing each tuple in the globals().items() list with the function lambda x: var is globals()[x[0]]. In that function x is the tuple being tested; x[0] is the variable name (as a string) and x[1] is the value. The lambda function tests whether the value of the tested variable is the same as the value of the variable passed to variablename(). In fact, by using the is operator, the lambda function tests whether the name of the tested variable is bound to the exact same object as the variable passed to variablename(). If so, the tuple passes the test and is returned by ifilter().
The itertools.ifilter() function actually returns an iterator which doesn't return any results until it is called properly. To get it called properly, I put it inside a list comprehension [tpl[0] for tpl ... globals().items())]. The list comprehension saves only the variable name tpl[0], ignoring the variable value. The list that is created contains one or more names (as strings) that are bound to the value of the variable passed to variablename().
In the uses of variablename() shown below, the desired string is returned as an element in a list. In many cases, it will be the only item in the list. If another variable name is assigned the same value, however, the list will be longer.
>>> def variablename(var):
... import itertools
... return [tpl[0] for tpl in
... itertools.ifilter(lambda x: var is x[1], globals().items())]
...
>>> var = {}
>>> variablename(var)
['var']
>>> something_else = 3
>>> variablename(something_else)
['something_else']
>>> yet_another = 3
>>> variablename(something_else)
['yet_another', 'something_else']