from __future__ import annotations
Mandatory as in coming by default.
Optional as in needed to be "activated" from an from __future__ import annotations
statement
Mandatory is an interesting word choice. I guess it means that it's by default in the language. You don't have to enable it with from __future__ import annotations
The annotations
feature are referring to the PEP 563: Postponed evaluation of annotations. It's an enhancement to the existing annotations feature which was initially introduced in python 3.0 and redefined as type hints in python 3.5, that's why your code works under python 3.8.
Here's what optional from __future__ import annotations
changes in python 3.7+:
class A:
def f(self) -> A: # NameError: name 'A' is not defined
pass
but this works
from __future__ import annotations
class A:
def f(self) -> A:
pass
See this chapter in python 3.7 what's new about postponed annotations:
Since this change breaks compatibility, the new behavior needs to be enabled on a per-module basis in Python 3.7 using a
__future__
import:
from __future__ import annotations
It will become the default in Python 3.10*.
* it was announced to be default in 3.10 (when python3.7 was released), but it was now moved to a later release