Convert java to kotlin on paste

In my case I needed to have the "Do you want to convert ..." dialog again, despite the option to convert checked.

1. Preferences -> Editor -> General -> Smart Keys -> Scroll to the end -> Convert posted Java code to Kotlin (checked)
2. Preferences -> Editor -> General -> Smart Keys -> Scroll to the end -> Don't show Java to Kotlin conversion dialog on paste (unchecked)
3. File -> Invalidate Caches / Restart

Preferences -> Editor -> General -> Smart Keys -> Convert pasted Java code to Kotlin (at the end of the page)