How do you find the original user through multiple sudo and su commands?
There's no perfect answer. When you change user IDs, the original user ID is not usually preserved, so the information is lost. Some programs, such as logname
and who -m
implement a hack where they check to see which terminal is connected to stdin
, and then check to see what user is logged in on that terminal.
This solution often works, but isn't foolproof, and certainly shouldn't be considered secure. For example, imagine if who
outputs the following:
tom pts/0 2011-07-03 19:18 (1.2.3.4)
joe pts/1 2011-07-03 19:10 (5.6.7.8)
tom
used su
to get to root, and runs your program. If STDIN
is not redirected, then a program like logname
will output tom
. If it IS redirected (e.g. from a file) as so:
logname < /some/file
Then the result is "no login name
", since the input isn't the terminal. More interestingly still, though, is the fact that the user could pose as a different logged in user. Since Joe is logged in on pts/1, Tom could pretend to be him by running
logname < /dev/pts1
Now, it says joe
even though tom is the one who ran the command. In other words, if you use this mechanism in any sort of security role, you're crazy.
Results:
Use who am i | awk '{print $1}'
OR logname
as no other methods are guaranteed.
Logged in as self:
evan> echo $USER
evan
evan> echo $SUDO_USER
evan> echo $LOGNAME
evan
evan> whoami
evan
evan> who am i | awk '{print $1}'
evan
evan> logname
evan
evan>
Normal sudo:
evan> sudo -s
root> echo $USER
root
root> echo $SUDO_USER
evan
root> echo $LOGNAME
root
root> whoami
root
root> who am i | awk '{print $1}'
evan
root> logname
evan
root>
sudo su - :
evan> sudo su -
[root ]# echo $USER
root
[root ]# echo $SUDO_USER
[root ]# echo $LOGNAME
root
[root ]# whoami
root
[root ]# who am i | awk '{print $1}'
evan
[root ]# logname
evan
[root ]#
sudo su -; su tom :
evan> sudo su -
[root ]# su tom
tom$ echo $USER
tom
tom$ echo $SUDO_USER
tom$ echo $LOGNAME
tom
tom$ whoami
tom
tom$ who am i | awk '{print $1}'
evan
tom$ logname
evan
tom$
This is a ksh
function I wrote on HP-UX. I don't know how it will work with Bash
in Linux. The idea is that the sudo
process is running as the original user and the child processes are the target user. By cycling back through parent processes, we can find the user of the original process.
#
# The options of ps require UNIX_STD=2003. I am setting it
# in a subshell to avoid having it pollute the parent's namespace.
#
function findUser
{
thisPID=$$
origUser=$(whoami)
thisUser=$origUser
while [ "$thisUser" = "$origUser" ]
do
( export UNIX_STD=2003; ps -p$thisPID -ouser,ppid,pid,comm ) | grep $thisPID | read thisUser myPPid myPid myComm
thisPID=$myPPid
done
if [ "$thisUser" = "root" ]
then
thisUser=$origUser
fi
if [ "$#" -gt "0" ]
then
echo $origUser--$thisUser--$myComm
else
echo $thisUser
fi
return 0
}
I know the original question was from a long time ago but people (such as me) are still asking and this looked like a good place to put the solution.