How to determine if a point lies on the same side of the plane that origin does?

Basic method

Simply plug in both points $A=(2,-1,1)$ and $O=(0,0,0)$ to the expression: $$ 5x-3y+z-18 $$ and compare signs. A point to the same side of the plane as the direction of the normal vector $\vec n=(5,-3,1)$ will result in a positive value of the expression above, whereas a point in the plane results in the value zero, and a point opposite the normal vector yields a negative value. $$ 5\cdot 2-3\cdot(-1)+1-18=10+3+1-18=-4 $$ and for $(0,0,0)$ all terms but $-18$ vanish, so indeed they both lie opposite $\vec n$. In the negative half-space defined by the plane and the normal vector.


Background

enter image description here

The reason for this is that the plane equation has come about based on the dot product: $$ a(x-x_0)+b(y-y_0)+c(z-z_0)=0 $$ where we have the normal vector $$ \vec n= \begin{pmatrix} a\\ b\\ c\end{pmatrix} $$ and the vector from a point in the plane $P=(x_0,y_0,z_0)$ to a variable point $Q=(x,y,z)$: $$ \overrightarrow{PQ}= \begin{pmatrix} x-x_0\\ y-y_0\\ z-z_0\end{pmatrix} $$ Considering the well-known result $\vec v\cdot\vec w=|\vec v||\vec w|\cos(\varphi)$ for two vectors $\vec v,\vec w$ and the angle $\varphi$ between them, we have:

  • $\vec v\perp\vec w\iff \vec v\cdot\vec w=0$
  • $\varphi=\angle(\vec v,\vec w)<90^\circ\iff \vec v\cdot\vec w>0$ (positive dot product implies normal vector in same direction as vector from $P$ in plane to $Q$)
  • $\varphi=\angle(\vec v,\vec w)>90^\circ\iff \vec v\cdot\vec w<0$ (negative dot product implies normal vector in opposite direction as vector from $P$ in plane to $Q$)

The line $(x,y,z)=(2,-1,1)t$ passes through the origin, and your point. Consider values of the form $$A=5(2t)-3(-t)+t-18.$$ Solving for the value of $t$ that makes $A$ zero tells us the value of $t$ when the line passes through the plane. If that value of $t$ is between $0$ and $1$, the line passes through the plane after leaving the origin, but before arriving at your point, so the two points are on different sides. If $t<0$ or $t>1$, then the line intersects both points either before or after intersecting the plane, so they are on the same side.


Let $F(x,y,z)=5x-3y+z-18$. The plane is defined by $F(x,y,z)=0$. Then check $$ F(2,-1,1)=10+3+1-18=-4 < 0 \\ F(0,0,0) = -18 < 0. $$ These points are on the same side of the plane.