How to enforce the 'override' keyword?
There are few ways to do this in VC++ and equivalent ways with GCC as well.
VC++
Below are the relevant warning numbers in VC++ using Code Quality CppCoreCheck:
[C26435][2] : “Function should specify exactly one of ‘virtual’, ‘override’, or ‘final’.”
[C26433][1] : “Function should be marked with override”
To enable these two warnings:
Open the
Property Pages
dialog for your project.Select the
Configuration Properties
>Code Analysis
property page.Set the
Enable Code Analysis
onBuild
andEnable Microsoft Code Analysis
properties.Select the
Configuration Properties
>Code Analysis
>Microsoft
property page.Setup the active rules (e.g.:
C++ Core Check Class Rules
contains these 2 checkers)
GCC
GCC 5.1+ has added new warning suggest-override that you can pass as command line option -Wsuggest-override
.
Clang
Clang 3.5+ has -Winconsistent-missing-override
, however this only detects cases if some overriding memebers or base classes use override
but other overriding members do not. You might want to take a look at clang-tidy tool as well.
C++11 almost had what you want.
Originally the override
keyword was part of a larger proposal (N2928) which also included the ability to enforce its usage:
class A
{
virtual void f();
};
class B [[base_check]] : public A
{
void f(); // error!
};
class C [[base_check]] : public A
{
void f [[override]] (); // OK
};
The base_check
attribute would make it an error to override a virtual function without using the override
keyword.
There was also a hiding
attribute which says a function hides functions in the base class. If base_check
is used and a function hides one from the base class without using hiding
it's an error.
But most of the proposal was dropped and only the final
and override
features were kept, as "identifiers with special meaning" rather than attributes.