How to get exact roots of this polynomial?
Since we ask if the numbers $\;x_n = \cos(\frac{2n\pi}{11})\;$ are the actual roots of the polynomial :
p[x_] := 64 x^7 - 112 x^5 - 8 x^4 + 56 x^3 + 8 x^2 - 7 x - 1
any numerical approach cannot be sufficient and in order to prove the statement we should proceed with a symbolic approach. Nevertheless NSolve
may guarantee that all the roots could be represented in terms of values of trigonometrical functions like Sin
or Cos
for real arguments since we have :
And @@ ( -1 <= x <= 1 /. NSolve[ p[x] == 0, x] )
True
The five of the roots are represented in terms of the Root
objects, and only two of them have been rewritten by built-in rewrite rules as rational numbers :
r = List @@ Roots[64 x^7 - 112 x^5 - 8 x^4 + 56 x^3 + 8 x^2 - 7 x - 1 == 0, x][[All, 2]];
r[[5 ;;]]
{ Root[1 + 6 #1 - 12 #1^2 - 32 #1^3 + 16 #1^4 + 32 #1^5 &, 5], -(1/2), 1}
Now we can experss r[[;;5]]
in terms of Cos
(it is possible as we have shown above), we can do it this way :
ArcCos @ r[[;; 5]] // FullSimplify
{ 10π/11, 8π/11, 6 π/11, 4π/11, 2π/11}
We might also use ArcSin
as well. Let`s verify if they are equal :
Table[ Root[1 + 6 #1 - 12 #1^2 - 32 #1^3 + 16 #1^4 + 32 #1^5 &, k] - Cos[2(6 - k)π/11],
{k, 5}] // RootReduce
{0, 0, 0, 0, 0}
Well, indeed these are the roots of the polynomial $p(x)$. One observes that FullSimplify
cannot reduce the above Table
with the standard built-in rewrite rules unless one uses e.g. Table[ Root[...] - Cos[...], {k,5}]// FullSimplify[#, TransformationFunctions -> RootReduce]&
.
Another way which might be helpful in more involved cases would be e.g. mapping PossibleZeroQ
, however we have to remember that PossibleZeroQ
provides a quick but not always accurate test.
Edit
Since all the roots can be represented as Sin
or Cos
for real arguments, it would be a good idea to explain what is so specific behind the polynomial p[x]
. We can reach a general view working with a transformation pointed out by whuber in the comments.
g[z_] := (p[x] /. x -> (z + 1/z)/2) 2 z^Exponent[p[x], x]
g[z] // Factor
(-1 + z)^2 (1 + z + z^2) (1 + z + z^2 + z^3 + z^4 + z^5 + z^6 + z^7 + z^8 + z^9 + z^10)
All the roots of g[z]
are roots of unity :
And @@ RootOfUnityQ[ List @@ Roots[ g[z] == 0, z][[All, 2]] ]
True
moreover all the polynomial factors of g[z]
are cyclotomic polynomials, respectively $C^{2}_{1}(z)$, $C_{3}(z)$ and $C_{11}(z)$ (see Cyclotomic
), so we have :
Times @@ (Cyclotomic[#, z] & /@ {1, 1, 3, 11}) == g[z] // Factor
True
Following in reverse direction we would generate more polynomials with the roots expressible in terms of $\sin$ or $\cos$ functions on rational multiples of $\pi$.
Element[Cos[Pi/11], Algebraics]
(*True*)
ExpToTrig /@ Factor[-1 - 7 x + 8 x^2 + 56 x^3 - 8 x^4 - 112 x^5 + 64 x^7, Extension -> Cos[Pi/11]]
(*Or ComplexExpand*)
(*(-1+x) (1+2 x) (-2 x-2 Cos[π/11]) (2 x-2 Cos[(2 π)/11]) (2 x-2 Sin[(3 π)/22]) (-2 x-2 Sin[(5 π)/22]) (1+2 x-2 Cos[π/11]+2 Cos[(2 π)/11]+2 Sin[(3 π)/22]-2 Sin[(5 π)/22])*)
x /. Solve[% == 0, x]
(*{-(1/2), 1, -Cos[π/11], Cos[(2 π)/11], Sin[(3 π)/22], -Sin[(5 π)/22],
1/2 (-1 + 2 Cos[π/11] - 2 Cos[(2 π)/11] - 2 Sin[(3 π)/22] + 2 Sin[(5 π)/22])}*)
Okay, sometimes you get so involved in an idea that you don't realize how foolish it is. I was fooled or seduced by the simplicity of the Chebyshev expansion. Basically, my original answer was a complicated way to do this:
cosEq = 64 x^7 - 112 x^5 - 8 x^4 + 56 x^3 + 8 x^2 - 7 x - 1 /. x -> Cos[Pi t] //TrigToExp;
t /. Solve[cosEq == 0 && 0 <= t <= 1, t]
(* {0, 0, 2/11, 4/11, 6/11, 2/3, 8/11, 10/11} *)
The fundamental, simple idea is that if you think the solutions can be expressed in terms of cosine, then replacing the variable by cosine is a natural thing to try. If the angles are rational multiples of Pi
, then x -> Cos[Pi t]
will probably be a convenient substitution for determining which multiples.
Note that some cosines are automatically converted to sines by Mathematica.
Cos[Pi %]
(* {1, 1, Cos[(2 π)/11], Sin[(3 π)/22], -Sin[π/22], -(1/2), -Sin[(5 π)/22], -Cos[π/11]} *)
The simple root x == 1
(or t == 0
) appears twice because Cos[Pi t] == 1
has a double root.
If one would like to have unique solutions in terms of cosines for output-formatting purposes, then one could do something like
HoldForm[Cos[t Pi]] /. DeleteDuplicates@ Solve[TrigToExp[cosEq] == 0 && 0 <= t <= 1];
% /. HoldForm[x_?NumberQ] :> HoldForm[Evaluate@ x]
Original answer
Basically I converted the OP's polynomial to
-ChebyshevT[4, x] + ChebyshevT[7, x]
which can be replaced by
-Cos[4 Pi t] + Cos[7 Pi t]
whose roots are easy to find by hand. To use Mathematica to get the solutions, I had to use TrigToExp
, as I did above. See edit history for full discussion.