Is there a better alternative than this to 'switch on type'?
With C# 7, which shipped with Visual Studio 2017 (Release 15.*), you are able to use Types in case
statements (pattern matching):
switch(shape)
{
case Circle c:
WriteLine($"circle with radius {c.Radius}");
break;
case Rectangle s when (s.Length == s.Height):
WriteLine($"{s.Length} x {s.Height} square");
break;
case Rectangle r:
WriteLine($"{r.Length} x {r.Height} rectangle");
break;
default:
WriteLine("<unknown shape>");
break;
case null:
throw new ArgumentNullException(nameof(shape));
}
With C# 6, you can use a switch statement with the nameof() operator (thanks @Joey Adams):
switch(o.GetType().Name) {
case nameof(AType):
break;
case nameof(BType):
break;
}
With C# 5 and earlier, you could use a switch statement, but you'll have to use a magic string containing the type name... which is not particularly refactor friendly (thanks @nukefusion)
switch(o.GetType().Name) {
case "AType":
break;
}
Switching on types is definitely lacking in C# (UPDATE: in C#7 / VS 2017 switching on types is supported - see Zachary Yates's answer). In order to do this without a large if/else if/else statement, you'll need to work with a different structure. I wrote a blog post awhile back detailing how to build a TypeSwitch structure.
https://docs.microsoft.com/archive/blogs/jaredpar/switching-on-types
Short version: TypeSwitch is designed to prevent redundant casting and give a syntax that is similar to a normal switch/case statement. For example, here is TypeSwitch in action on a standard Windows form event
TypeSwitch.Do(
sender,
TypeSwitch.Case<Button>(() => textBox1.Text = "Hit a Button"),
TypeSwitch.Case<CheckBox>(x => textBox1.Text = "Checkbox is " + x.Checked),
TypeSwitch.Default(() => textBox1.Text = "Not sure what is hovered over"));
The code for TypeSwitch is actually pretty small and can easily be put into your project.
static class TypeSwitch {
public class CaseInfo {
public bool IsDefault { get; set; }
public Type Target { get; set; }
public Action<object> Action { get; set; }
}
public static void Do(object source, params CaseInfo[] cases) {
var type = source.GetType();
foreach (var entry in cases) {
if (entry.IsDefault || entry.Target.IsAssignableFrom(type)) {
entry.Action(source);
break;
}
}
}
public static CaseInfo Case<T>(Action action) {
return new CaseInfo() {
Action = x => action(),
Target = typeof(T)
};
}
public static CaseInfo Case<T>(Action<T> action) {
return new CaseInfo() {
Action = (x) => action((T)x),
Target = typeof(T)
};
}
public static CaseInfo Default(Action action) {
return new CaseInfo() {
Action = x => action(),
IsDefault = true
};
}
}