Java Swing revalidate() vs repaint()

Any time you do a remove() or a removeAll(), you should call

  validate();
  repaint();

after you have completed add()'ing the new components.

Calling validate() or revalidate() is mandatory when you do a remove() - see the relevant javadocs.

My own testing indicates that repaint() is also necessary. I'm not sure exactly why.

You need to call repaint() and revalidate(). The former tells Swing that an area of the window is dirty (which is necessary to erase the image of the old children removed by removeAll()); the latter tells the layout manager to recalculate the layout (which is necessary when adding components). This should cause children of the panel to repaint, but may not cause the panel itself to do so (see this for the list of repaint triggers).

On a more general note: rather than reusing the original panel, I'd recommend building a new panel and swapping them at the parent.

revalidate is called on a container once new components are added or old ones removed. this call is an instruction to tell the layout manager to reset based on the new component list. revalidate will trigger a call to repaint what the component thinks are 'dirty regions.' Obviously not all of the regions on your JPanel are considered dirty by the RepaintManager.

repaint is used to tell a component to repaint itself. It is often the case that you need to call this in order to cleanup conditions such as yours.