Manually Add Program to Open With in Windows 10

I think you should retry Default Programs Editor.

Don't click on "Context Menu" but rather on the option at the bottom - "Change'Open with' programs":

enter image description here

and then:

enter image description here

You may need to restart you computer for changes to appear.

Another excellent tool is OpenWithView, by Nir Sofer.

It is very much worth checking his other free tools.

Related