Use of special characters in function names

I'm not a big fan of special characters in function names, but then I'll also beat to death, with a stick of wet celery to tease out the pain, anyone I find putting spaces into file names :-)

The ? variant can just as easily be done with something like isEmpty() and the ! variant with sortInPlace().

English is a very adaptive language, even without the punctuation.

In either case, my languages of choice (C and Java) use punctuation for all sorts of other things. Having them in identifiers as well would make the lexical analysis a nightmare.

The answer is, of course, language (and language culture) specific.

For example, depending on the language, all of the following are appropriate: empty-p, empty?, empty, is_empty or isEmpty. (These examples are, of course, not inclusive).

The examples in the original question come from Ruby where such use of ? and ! to end method names are, where appropriate, accepted. This acceptance comes from 1) readily accessible as symbol terminators in the grammar 2) use of ? and ! in the standard library. However, it should be note that ! is not used universally to imply "side-effect" and is generally only present on alternative forms: save/save!, sort/sort!, etc. There are an overwhelming number of methods that perform side-effects which do not have the ! prefix.

Personally, if I was designing a language, I would allow ?, ! and ' to be valid unquoted trailing characters in symbol names. Even though that some languages allow full symbol escaping, such as Scala, such symbols are usually avoided because it's a pain to have to quote them for use.

// in Scala, esp. with Java-compat, the last form is generally used although
// the first two are perfectly valid -- do what makes sense in the language
foo.`empty?`
foo.empty_?
foo.isEmpty

When in Rome...

• Scala - empty? or empty_? (not common)
• C/C++/JS/Java/Python/Perl - no ? or ! in identifiers; JS/Java allow $; $ is a sigil in Perl
• C/C++/Perl/JS - hands up in the air?
• C# - IsEmpty (method or property) or Empty (property)
• Python - is_empty or isEmpty per Guido-guide (although usually len protocol: if not len(foo): "empty!")
• Java - isEmpty per Language Guide
• Ruby - special trailing ? and ! (quoting?)
• JS - indirect identifier access: obj["empty?"] (not common for this)
• Lisp (conventional): empty-p for predicate; variations in reader/quoting
• Julia - appends ! to functions that modify their arguments

Glad to see corrections and/or additions -- is only a drop in a bucket.