When citing an arXiv paper, what year should one write?

I would cite the exact version you are referring to in your work. Therefore the year should be the year of that version. You should also use the actual arxiv identifier in the citation. This is to minimise the effect of potential changes in the cited work on your paper. Moreover, your goal is to provide the reader with a precise pointer to the cited work so that they can easily find it.

In this case I would likely go with the date of the original posting, unless there are fairly significant differences between versions (a paper might have its title changed, or results noticeably broadened or restricted from the original posting, for any number of reasons). One way or another, it is highly recommended to have an "accessed on" date in the bibliography entry for any citation of online materials, such as arxiv preprints. It would be naturally assumed that you were consulting the most recent version of the posting available at that time, and not later or earlier ones, which is easily determined and accessed (at least in the case of the arxiv). Without this the reference can otherwise be problematically ambiguous, as it is entirely possible that the cited preprint will get a new version at several stages during the process of getting your own published, and the cited article may get published and get new arxiv versions after your own has been published and given a "final" arxiv update.