IntPtr arithmetics
You have four options that I can think of, two using only "safe" code, and two using unsafe code. The unsafe options are likely to be significantly faster.
Safe:
Allocate your array in managed memory, and declare your P/Invoke function to take the array. i.e., instead of:
[DllImport(...)] static extern bool Foo(int count, IntPtr arrayPtr);
make it
[DllImport(...)] static extern bool Foo(int count, NativeType[] array);
(I've used
NativeType
for your struct name instead ofT
, sinceT
is often used in a generic context.)The problem with this approach is that, as I understand it, the
NativeType[]
array will be marshaled twice for every call toFoo
. It will be copied from managed memory to unmanaged memory before the call, and copied from unmanaged memory to managed memory afterward. It can be improved, though, ifFoo
will only read from or write to the array. In this case, decorate thetarray
parameter with an[In]
(read only) or[Out]
(write only) attribute. This allows the runtime to skip one of the copying steps.As you're doing now, allocate the array in unmanaged memory, and use a bunch of calls to
Marshal.PtrToStructure
andMarshal.StructureToPtr
. This will likely perform even worse than the first option, as you still need to copy elements of the array back and forth, and you're doing it in steps, so you have more overhead. On the other hand, if you have many elements in the array, but you only access a small number of them in between calls toFoo
, then this may perform better. You might want a couple of little helper functions, like so:static T ReadFromArray<T>(IntPtr arrayPtr, int index){ // below, if you **know** you'll be on a 32-bit platform, // you can change ToInt64() to ToInt32(). return (T)Marshal.PtrToStructure((IntPtr)(arrayPtr.ToInt64() + index * Marshal.SizeOf(typeof(T))); } // you might change `T value` below to `ref T value` to avoid one more copy static void WriteToArray<T>(IntPtr arrayPtr, int index, T value){ // below, if you **know** you'll be on a 32-bit platform, // you can change ToInt64() to ToInt32(). Marshal.StructureToPtr(value, (IntPtr)(arrayPtr.ToInt64() + index * Marshal.SizeOf(typeof(T)), false); }
Unsafe:
Allocate your array in unmanaged memory, and use pointers to access the elements. This means that all the code that uses the array must be within an
unsafe
block.IntPtr arrayPtr = Marhsal.AllocHGlobal(count * sizeof(typeof(NativeType))); unsafe{ NativeType* ptr = (NativeType*)arrayPtr.ToPointer(); ptr[0].Member1 = foo; ptr[1].Member2 = bar; /* and so on */ } Foo(count, arrayPtr);
Allocate your array in managed memory, and pin it when you need to call the native routine:
NativeType[] array = new NativeType[count]; array[0].Member1 = foo; array[1].Member2 = bar; /* and so on */ unsafe{ fixed(NativeType* ptr = array) Foo(count, (IntPtr)ptr); // or just Foo(count, ptr), if Foo is declare as such: // static unsafe bool Foo(int count, NativeType* arrayPtr); }
This last option is probably the cleanest if you can use unsafe code and are concerned about performance, because your only unsafe code is where you call the native routine. If performance isn't an issue (perhaps if the size of the array is relatively small), or if you can't use unsafe code (perhaps you don't have full trust), then the first option is likely cleanest, although, as I mentioned, if the number of elements you'll access in between calls to the native routine are a small percentage of the number of elements within the array, then the second option is faster.
Note:
The unsafe operations assume that your struct is blittable. If not, then the safe routines are your only option.
"Why
IntPtr
lack of arithmetics?"
IntPtr
stores just a memory address. It doesn't have any kind of information about the contents of that memory location. In this manner, it's similar to void*
. To enable pointer arithmetic you have to know the size of the object pointed to.
Fundamentally, IntPtr
is primarily designed to be used in managed contexts as an opaque handle (i.e. one that you don't directly dereference in managed code and you just keep around to pass to unmanaged code.) unsafe
context provides pointers you can manipulate directly.
Indeed, the IntPtr
type does not have its own arithmetic operators. Proper (unsafe) pointer arithmetic is supported in C#, but IntPtr
and the Marshal
class exist for 'safer' usage of pointers.
I think you want something like the following:
int index = 1; // 2nd element of array
var v = (T)Marshal.PtrToStructure(new IntPtr(data.ToInt32() +
index * Marshal.SizeOf(typeof(T)), typeof(T));
Also, note that IntPtr
has no implicit conversion between int
and IntPtr
, so no luck there.
Generally, if you're going to be doing anything remotely complex with pointers, it's probably best to opt for unsafe code.