Limit superior and inferior reference request.

If it is exercises that you're looking for:

I would suggest that you look into the three volume book: Problems in Mathematical Analysis, by W J Kaczor and M T Nowak, Marie Curie-Sklodowska University, Lublin, Poland . This is published by the American Mathematical Society.

The table of contents may be accessed from the links to AMS page here.

  • The first volume deals with real numbers; sequences and series. This book is a very ideal start into a first course in Analysis. Amazing collection of problems. There are a lot of challenges. Some of the well known (read: hard) problems are given as exercises here. But, the necessay machinery is built by supplementing this with small toy problems. I learnt a lot from this book.

Randomly Chosen Problems from Vol. I:

$\hskip{1.8 in}$ enter image description here

  • The second volume deals with Continuity and Differentiability of Real-valued functions. The emphasis on semi-continuous functions; functions of Dirichlet's type are amazing. Some nice exercises as applications of Mean Value Theorem. There are lot of nice ideas in this book.

Randomly Chosen Problems from Vol. II:

$\hskip{1.2 in}$enter image description here

  • The third volume covers the theory of Riemann and Lebesgue integrals. The collection of problems is richer than what is seen in any text book. They are also arranged beautifully.

Random Page from Vol. III: (Courtesy: the user t.b.)

$\hskip{1.8 in}$enter image description here

There are solutions that give hints--just about what is required to complete the problems. (I would view the solutions as complete; but it refers to previous exercises and you'll end up tracing a chain if you don't take the hints that are there.)

P.S. (The Indian Editions costs Rs. 800 each volume. Looking hard enough will get you these books from somewhere...)


The first 2 volumes of Kaczor/Nowak have a large number of such exercises scattered throughout. Also, McShane's classic book on Lebesgue integration gives a well written and leisurely treatment. In the U.S., at least, you can find McShane's text in most every college and university library.

Kaczor/Nowak, Problems in Mathematical Analysis, Volumes 1 & 2, American Mathematical Society.

Edward James McShane, Integration, Princeton Mathematical Series, 1944, viii + 394 pages. [My copy is the 1974 8th printing.]

(added next day) After looking at McShane's book, I agree with the comments I wrote yesterday. It gives a very well written discussion of $\limsup$ and $\liminf$ for functions in Article 6 (pp. 26-38). Also, Article 7 (pp. 38-44) is nicely done. Below are 3 additional books that you might find useful (in light of your comment "Spivak's type of excercises"), but which don't specifically devote all that much to $\limsup$ and $\liminf$ for functions (at least, not together in one section).

Ralph Philip Boas, A Primer of Real Functions, 4th edition prepared by Harold Philip Boas, Mathematical Association of America, 1996, xiv + 305 pages.

Andrew Michael Bruckner, Judith Brostoff Bruckner, and Brian S. Thomson, Elementary Real Analysis, Prentice-Hall, 2001, xvi + 677 + 58 pages. [The final 58 pages consist of appendixes: (A) Background, (B) Hints for Selected Exercises, (C) Subject Index.]

Edgar Terome Townsend, Functions of Real Variables, Henry Holt and Company, 1928, xii + 405 pages.

Finally, more advanced readers of this thread may be interested in the following paper, which gives (on pp. 429-430) some relations involving mixed iterations of the operations $\limsup$ and $\liminf$ of a function at a point.

Robert Palmer Dilworth, The normal completion of the lattice of continuous functions, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 68 (1950), 427-438.

http://www.ams.org/journals/tran/1950-068-03/S0002-9947-1950-0034822-9/