-> operator in Clojure

It is also worth noting that there is a ->> macro which will thread the form as the last argument:

(->> a (+ 5) (let [a 5] ))

The Joy of Clojure, chapter 8.1 talks about this subject a bit.


No, they are not the same. Clojure doesn't really have a need for |> because all function calls are enclosed in lists, like (+ 1 2): there's no magic you could do to make 1 + 2 work in isolation.1

-> is for reducing nesting and simplifying common patterns. For example:

(-> x (assoc :name "ted") (dissoc :size) (keys))

Expands to

(keys (dissoc (assoc x :name "ted") :size))

The former is often easier to read, because conceptually you're performing a series of operations on x; the former code is "shaped" that way, while the latter needs some mental unraveling to work out.

1 You can write a macro that sorta makes this work. The idea is to wrap your macro around the entire source tree that you want to transform, and let it look for |> symbols; it can then transform the source into the shape you want. Hiredman has made it possible to write code in a very Haskell-looking way, with his functional package.


It's called the "thread" operator. It's written as a macro as opposed to a normal function for performance reasons and so that it can provide a nice syntax - i.e. it applies the transformation at compile time.

It's somewhat more powerful than the |> operator you describe, as it's intended to pass a value through several functions, where each successive value is "inserted" as the first parameter of the following function calls. Here's a somewhat contrived example:

(-> [1]
     (concat [2 3 4])
     (sum)
     ((fn [x] (+ x 100.0))))
=> 110.0

If you want to define a function exactly like the F# operator you have described, you can do:

(defn |> [x f] (f x))

(|> 3 inc)
=> 4

Not sure how useful that really is, but there you are anyway :-)

Finally, if you want to pass a value through a sequence of functions, you can always do something like the following in clojure:

(defn pipeline [x & fns]
  ((apply comp fns) x))

(pipeline 1 inc inc inc inc)
=> 5