PHP preg_replace non-greedy trouble

Your non-greedy modifier is working as expected. But preg_match replaces all occurences of the the (non-greedy) match with the replacement text ("" in your case). If you want only the first one replaced, you could pass 1 as the optional 4th argument (limit) to preg_replace function (PHP docs for preg_replace). On the website you linked, this can be accomplished by typing 1 into the text input between the word "Flags" and the word "limit".