sizeof(long) in 64-bit C++
Because it doesn't have to be. The C++ standard only requires that it is (if memory serves) at least 32 bits wide, and at least as big as int
.
MSVC (and the ABI used by Windows) defines long
to be 32 bits wide, and MingW follows suit because well, the compiler is a lot more useful when it agrees with the host OS
On the microsoft windows OS you have LLP64 so the size of long is 32 bit. (see the table below)
Quote from wikipedia:
In 32-bit programs, pointers and data types such as integers generally have the same length; this is not necessarily true on 64-bit machines. Mixing data types in programming languages such as C and its descendants such as C++ and Objective-C may thus function on 32-bit implementations but not on 64-bit implementations. In many programming environments for C and C-derived languages on 64-bit machines, "int" variables are still 32 bits wide, but long integers and pointers are 64 bits wide. These are described as having an LP64 data model. Another alternative is the ILP64 data model in which all three data types are 64 bits wide, and even SILP64 where "short" integers are also 64 bits wide. However, in most cases the modifications required are relatively minor and straightforward, and many well-written programs can simply be recompiled for the new environment without changes. Another alternative is the LLP64 model, which maintains compatibility with 32-bit code by leaving both int and long as 32-bit. "LL" refers to the "long long integer" type, which is at least 64 bits on all platforms, including 32-bit environments.
Type ILP64 LP64 LLP64
char 8 8 8
short 16 16 16
int 64 32 32
long 64 64 32
long long 64 64 64
pointer 64 64 64
MinGW is designed to build Windows applications, and the Microsoft platform ABI specifies that int
and long
have the same size of 32 bits. If MinGW defined long
differently from MSVC, most existing Windows apps that use long
would break when compiled using MinGW.
Having said that, Cygwin x86_64 does follow the LP64 convention on Windows, just like on Linux (source).
So you can use that to build a Windows app where the size of long
is 8 bytes :)
Test case:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <windows.h>
int CALLBACK WinMain(HINSTANCE a, HINSTANCE b, LPSTR c, int d)
{
char buf[100];
snprintf(buf, sizeof(buf),
"sizeof(int)=%d, sizeof(long)=%d, sizeof(long long)=%d\n",
sizeof(int), sizeof(long), sizeof(long long));
MessageBox(NULL, buf, "Cygwin Test", MB_OK);
return 0;
}
Compile with: C:\cygwin64\bin\gcc.exe -mwindows -m64 cygwin-test.c -o cygwin-test
Output: