What are Alternative's "some" and "many" useful for?
TL;DR: some
is one or more, many
is 0 or more results collected from performing the same computation over and over by the familiar maximal munch rule. For this to make sense, some state passing (and alteration) must take place reducing the domain of possibilities somehow, otherwise it will repeat ad infinitum. And state passing and parsing are closely related.
An elementary example instance: with
import Control.Monad(Functor(..))
import Control.Applicative
import Data.Char
-- char string parser
newtype P a = P { runP :: String -> [(a,String)] }
-- runP (P p) s = p s
instance Functor P where
-- fmap :: (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
fmap f (P q) = P (\s -> [ (f y,ys) | (y,ys) <- q s])
instance Applicative P where
-- pure :: a -> f a
pure x = P (\s -> [(x,s)])
-- (<*>) :: f (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
P p <*> P q = P (\s -> [(x y, ys) | (x,xs) <- p s, (y,ys) <- q xs])
letter = P p where -- sample parser
p (x:xs) | isAlpha x = [(x,xs)]
p _ = []
we have
*Main Data.Char> runP letter "123" [] *Main Data.Char> runP letter "a123" [('a',"123")] *Main Data.Char> runP ( (:) <$> letter <*> pure []) "a123" [("a","123")] *Main Data.Char> runP ( (:) <$> letter <*> ((:)<$>letter <*> pure []) ) "a123" [] *Main Data.Char> runP ( (:) <$> letter <*> ((:)<$>letter <*> pure []) ) "ab123" [("ab","123")] -- NOT NICE ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ -}
Then, with
instance Alternative P where
-- (<|>) :: f a -> f a -> f a
P p <|> P q = P (\s-> p s ++ q s)
-- empty :: f a -- the identity of <|>
empty = P (\s-> [])
we get
*Main Data.Char> runP (many letter) "ab123" [("ab","123"),("a","b123"),("","ab123")] *Main Data.Char> runP (some letter) "ab123" [("ab","123"),("a","b123")] *Main Data.Char> runP (optional letter) "ab123" [(Just 'a',"b123"),(Nothing,"ab123")] *Main Data.Char> runP (optional letter) "123" [(Nothing,"123")] Prelude Main Data.Traversable> runP (sequenceA $ replicate 2 letter) "ab123" [("ab","123")] -- NICE ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ -}
I tend to see them in Applicative
parser combinator libraries.
a :: Parser [String]
a = some (string "hello")
and I see many
used for purpose in the default definitions of Parsing
in parsers
.
I think Parsec being the primary example of a parser combinator library hides the use of some
/many
since it redefines things like (<|>)
.
In the STM Applicative, some
would mean: Keep trying until it succeeds at least once, and then keep doing it until it fails. many
would mean: Do this as many times as you can until failure.