Why does the CheckBoxFor render an additional input tag, and how can I get the value using the FormCollection?

Have a look here:

http://forums.asp.net/t/1314753.aspx

This isn't a bug, and is in fact the same approach that both Ruby on Rails and MonoRail use.

When you submit a form with a checkbox, the value is only posted if the checkbox is checked. So, if you leave the checkbox unchecked then nothing will be sent to the server when in many situations you would want false to be sent instead. As the hidden input has the same name as the checkbox, then if the checkbox is unchecked you'll still get a 'false' sent to the server.

When the checkbox is checked, the ModelBinder will automatically take care of extracting the 'true' from the 'true,false'

I had the same problem as Shawn (above). This approach might be great for POST, but it really sucks for GET. Therefore I implemented a simple Html extension that just whips out the hidden field.

public static MvcHtmlString BasicCheckBoxFor<T>(this HtmlHelper<T> html, 
                                                Expression<Func<T, bool>> expression,
                                                object htmlAttributes = null)
{
    var result = html.CheckBoxFor(expression).ToString();
    const string pattern = @"<input name=""[^""]+"" type=""hidden"" value=""false"" />";
    var single = Regex.Replace(result, pattern, "");
    return MvcHtmlString.Create(single);
}

The problem I now have is that I don't want a change to the MVC framework to break my code. So I have to ensure I have test coverage explaining this new contract.

I use this alternative method to render the checkboxes for GET forms:

/// <summary>
/// Renders checkbox as one input (normal Html.CheckBoxFor renders two inputs: checkbox and hidden)
/// </summary>
public static MvcHtmlString BasicCheckBoxFor<T>(this HtmlHelper<T> html, Expression<Func<T, bool>> expression, object htmlAttributes = null)
{
    var tag = new TagBuilder("input");

    tag.Attributes["type"] = "checkbox";
    tag.Attributes["id"] = html.IdFor(expression).ToString();
    tag.Attributes["name"] = html.NameFor(expression).ToString();
    tag.Attributes["value"] = "true";

    // set the "checked" attribute if true
    ModelMetadata metadata = ModelMetadata.FromLambdaExpression(expression, html.ViewData);
    if (metadata.Model != null)
    {
        bool modelChecked;
        if (Boolean.TryParse(metadata.Model.ToString(), out modelChecked))
        {
            if (modelChecked)
            {
                tag.Attributes["checked"] = "checked";
            }
        }
    }

    // merge custom attributes
    tag.MergeAttributes(HtmlHelper.AnonymousObjectToHtmlAttributes(htmlAttributes));

    var tagString = tag.ToString(TagRenderMode.SelfClosing);
    return MvcHtmlString.Create(tagString);
}

It's similar to Chris Kemp's method, which is working fine, except this one does not use the underlying CheckBoxFor and Regex.Replace. It's based on the source of the original Html.CheckBoxFor method.