Prevent ID autogeneration on copy-paste in Visual Studio 2008 ASP.NET Web Form
If you're on Visual Studio 2013, see this stackoverflow question:
Disable "Auto ID elements" in Visual Studio 2013
which basically points to a bug raised with Microsoft (disabling auto id has been removed from VS 2013):
http://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/806446/asp-net-web-forms-development-unable-to-disable-auto-id-generation-on-paste-using-new-version-of-visual-studio-2013
Options, Text Editor, HTML, Misc, Auto ID on Paste
By the way, the most similar article contains just the same question (answered, of course). Be more careful next time :)