Visitor pattern implementation in case of source code un-availability
You could combine a Wrapper and Visitor to solve your problems.
Using the wrapper to add a visit
method allows you to increase the usability of these objects. Of course you get the full advantages (less dependency on the legacy classes) and disadvantages (additional objects) of a wrapper.
Here's a worked-up example in JAVA (because it is pretty strict, does not do double-dispatch by itself, and I'm quite familiar with it):
1) Your legacy Objects
Assuming you have your legacy objects Legacy1
and Legacy2
which you cannot change, which have specific business methods:
public final class Legacy1 {
public void someBusinessMethod1(){
...
}
}
and
public final class Legacy2 {
public void anotherBusinessMethod(){
...
}
}
2) Prepare the Wrapper
You just wrap them in a VisitableWrapper which has a visit
method that takes your visitor, like:
public interface VisitableWrapper {
public void accept(Visitor visitor);
}
With the following implementations:
public class Legacy1Wrapper implements VisitableWrapper {
private final Legacy1 legacyObj;
public Legacy1Wrapper(Legacy1 original){
this.legacyObj = original;
}
public void accept(Visitor visitor){
visitor.visit(legacyObj);
}
}
and
public class Legacy2Wrapper implements VisitableWrapper {
private final Legacy2 legacyObj;
public Legacy2Wrapper(Legacy2 original){
this.legacyObj = original;
}
public void accept(Visitor visitor){
visitor.visit(legacyObj);
}
}
3) Visitor, at the ready!
Then your own Visitors can be set to visit the wrapper like so:
public interface Visitor {
public void visit(Legacy1 leg);
public void visit(Legacy2 leg);
}
With an implementation like so:
public class SomeLegacyVisitor{
public void visit(Legacy1 leg){
System.out.println("This is a Legacy1! let's do something with it!");
leg.someBusinessMethod1();
}
public void visit(Legacy2 leg){
System.out.println("Hum, this is a Legacy 2 object. Well, let's do something else.");
leg.anotherBusinessMethod();
}
}
4) Unleash the power
Finally in your code, this framework would work like this:
public class TestClass{
// Start off with some legacy objects
Legacy1 leg1 = ...
Legacy2 leg2 = ...
// Wrap all your legacy objects into a List:
List<VisitableWrapper> visitableLegacys = new ArrayList<>();
visitableLegacys.add(new Legacy1Wrapper(legacy1));
visitableLegacys.add(new Legacy2Wrapper(legacy2));
// Use any of your visitor implementations!
Visitor visitor = new SomeLegacyVisitor();
for(VisitableWrapper wrappedLegacy: visitableLegacys){
wrappedLegacy.accept(visitor);
}
}
The expected output:
This is a Legacy1! let's do something with it!
Hum, this is a Legacy 2 object. Well, let's do something else.
Drawbacks:
- Quite a lot of boilerplate. Use Lombok if you develop in Java.
- Quite a lot of wrapper objects instances. May or may not be a problem for you.
- You need to know the specific type of the objects beforehand. This implies you know their subtype, they aren't bundles in a List. If that's the case, you have no other option but to use reflection.