When I redirect the output of ls to a file, the filename is included in that file. How can I avoid this?
As you've noticed, the file is created before ls
is run. This is due to how the shell handles its order of operations. In order to do
ls > file
the shell needs to create file
and then set stdout to point to that and the finally run the ls
program.
So you have some options.
- Create the file in another directory (eg
/tmp
) and thenmv
it to the final directory - Create it as a hidden file (
.file
) and rename it - Use
grep
to remove the file from the output - Cheat :-)
The cheat would be something like
x=$(ls) ; printf "%s\n" "$x" > file
This causes the output of ls
to be held in a variable, and then we write that out.
The output file is created by the shell before ls
begins. You can get around this by using tee
:
ls | tee list
To thoroughly defeat any race condition, there is always
ls | grep -vx 'list' > list
Or if you like that tee
displays the results as well:
ls | grep -vx 'list' | tee list
However, as pointed out in comments, things like this often break when filenames contain strange characters. Unix filenames can generally contain any characters except for NUL
and /
, so parsing the output of ls
is extremely difficult:
- Assigning to a shell variable can fail if a filename ends in one or more
\n
. - Filtering with
grep
fails when the search term lies between\n
. - You can separate filenames with
NUL
instead of\n
usingfind
, but it can be difficult to convert this into something resembling the traditional sorted, newline-separated output ofls
. - Removing the output filename from the list may be incorrect if it already exists.
So the only truly effective way to do this is to create the output file somewhere else, and move it into place. If you will never use ls -a
, then this works:
ls > .list && mv .list list
If you might be using ls -a
, then .list
could appear in your output but no longer exist in the directory. So then you would use a different directory, like /tmp
to store the intermediate result. Of course, if you always use /tmp
you run into trouble there, so you can write a script:
#!/bin/sh
OUTDIR='/tmp'
if [ "${PWD}" = '/tmp' ]; then
OUTDIR="${HOME}"
fi
ls > "${OUTDIR}/list" && mv "${OUTDIR}/list" list
This seems overly complicated for the task, though.
But the entire cause of the issue is that the shell is creating the output file before the command begins. We can take that into consideration and just have the shell list the files for us. Then we don't even need ls
at all!
printf '%s\n' * > list
This will work until you have too many files in the directory to fit into an argument list.
You can make the filename temporarily hidden:
ls >.list && mv .list list