What is a good example to differentiate between fileprivate and private in Swift3
fileprivate
is now what private
used to be in earlier
Swift releases: accessible from
the same source file. A declaration marked as private
can now only be accessed within the lexical scope it is declared in.
So private
is more restrictive than fileprivate
.
As of Swift 4, private declarations inside a type are accessible to extensions of the same type if the extension is defined in the same source file.
Example (all in one source file):
class A {
private func foo() {}
fileprivate func bar() {}
func baz() {
foo()
bar()
}
}
extension A {
func test() {
foo() // Swift 3: error: use of unresolved identifier 'foo'
// Swift 4: no error because extension is in same source file
bar()
}
}
let a = A()
a.foo() // error: 'foo' is inaccessible due to 'private' protection level
a.bar()
The private
foo
method is accessible only within the scope of theclass A { ... }
definition. It is not even accessible from an extension to the type (in Swift 3, see the second note below for changes in Swift 4).The file-private
bar
method is accessible from the same source file.
Notes:
The proposal SE-0159 – Fix Private Access Levels suggested to revert to the Swift 2 semantics in Swift 4. After a lengthy and controversial discussion on the swift-evolution mailing list, the proposal was rejected.
The proposal SE-0169 – Improve Interaction Between private Declarations and Extensions suggests to make
private
declarations inside a type accessible to extensions of the same type if the extension is defined in the same source file. This proposal was accepted and implemented in Swift 4.
I just draw a diagram about private, fileprivate, open and public
Hope it can quickly help you , for text description please refer to Martin R 's answer
[ Update Swift 4, 5 ]
Updated for Swift 5
Private vs FilePrivate
For better clarity paste the code snippet in Playground
class Sum1 {
let a: Int!
let b: Int!
private var result: Int?
fileprivate var resultt: Int?
init(a : Int, b: Int) {
self.a = a
self.b = b
}
func sum(){
result = a + b
print(result as! Int)
}
}
let aObj = Sum1.init(a: 10, b: 20)
aObj.sum()
aObj.resultt //File Private Accessible as inside same swift file
aObj.result //Private varaible will not be accessible outside its definition except extensions
extension Sum1{
func testing() {
// Both private and fileprivate accessible in extensions
print(result)
print(resultt)
}
}
//If SUM2 class is created in same file as Sum1 ---
class Sum2{
func test(){
let aSum1 = Sum1.init(a: 2, b: 2)
// Only file private accessible
aSum1.resultt
}
}
Note: Outside of Swift file both private and fileprivate are not accessible.